.
Feedback

On Top of Everything Else, Obamacare Slaps Tax on Religious Freedom

Not only does health care law expands the role of government to unprecedented levels, its taxes also decimate our religious liberties.

The Affordable Care Act, often called Obamacare, gives the federal government the tools to tax religiously-affiliated schools, hospitals, universities and soup kitchens right out of existence if they object to a government mandate.

Last week, I voted to repeal Obamacare because the entire law is bad policy, the mandate expands the role of government to unprecedented levels, and the taxes decimate our religious liberties. This cannot stand.


We have heard a lot about the mandates in the law, but we have not heard much about these hidden taxes on religious freedom. Obamacare includes provisions that trigger penalties already written into our current tax code if the employer chooses not to comply, based on religious or moral convictions, with the Department of Health and Human Services mandate. The Internal Revenue Service allows the government to tax employers to the tune of $100 per day, per employee.

That equals an astounding $36,500 per employee, per year. If a religiously affiliated grade school has 50 employees, they would be taxed $1,825,000 per year, every year, just for exercising their constitutionally protected rights. With taxes so severe and burdensome, it’s hard to imagine that any institution could keep its doors open.

This is the question facing religious institutions and concerned employers today: will you violate your conscience and religious beliefs or pay a hefty tax to follow your faith?

Out of all the taxes in Obamacare, of which there are 21, this to me is the most egregious for its brazen disregard for religious liberty, one of the bedrocks of our country.

That’s why I introduced the Religious Freedom Tax Repeal Act of 2012. This bill will block the taxes that will be levied upon those religious institutions and those who have moral or religious objections in the private sector from having to pay for mandates under Obamacare that violate their religious or moral views.

How did we get to a place where our most precious freedoms are under attack? The Constitution stated: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.”

If you recall, in February, President Obama and his Department of Health and Human Services announced a “compromise” that was no compromise at all. When Americans across the country and across the political spectrum protested the HHS mandate, the president still decided to force religiously affiliated organizations and employers to facilitate a government mandate that violates core tenants of their faith.

The mandate also states that religious employers are exempt only if their purpose is to instill religious doctrine, to hire and serve exclusively people of their own faith, and qualify as a church or religious order according to a very narrow definition in the tax code.

Under this definition, even Jesus and Mother Theresa would not qualify, to say nothing of the religious charities that have provided relief and services throughout history. The exceptions are essentially irrelevant as most religious institutions providing health, educational or charitable services to others have no protection.

The Obama Administration is forcing employers to choose between either covering various drugs and services contrary to their religious beliefs or refusing to offer health plans to their employees and paying hefty taxes.

In addition to repealing the full law, I will continue to work in Congress with my co-sponsors to stop this religious freedom tax.

John Wilson July 16, 2012 at 02:10 pm
Parick - Pls keeping speaking TRUTH to STUPID... sooner or later - probably later - TRUTH will win the day...
John Wilson July 16, 2012 at 02:18 pm
Paul Callahan... Keith Best is correct on one point, Senselessbrenner is not a senator... of course, he is not a REAL congressman either!
No one wants their congressman to be devoid of all reason and blindly follow the path of the credit card companies that own him... Senselessbrenner has an OPINION on everything, even things not in existence yet, and the beauty of it all is that you do not even have to ask him for his opinion, he gives it freely... he may be seen talking to trees and lamp posts...
CowDung July 16, 2012 at 02:19 pm
What does Obamacare do that actually addresses the amount that Americans pay (on average) for healthcare?
Has Romneycare really been a success story in Massachusetts? You may call it successful because 98% of the people are covered, but many reports rate it as a dismal failure as costs have been spiraling out of control and access to healthcare has gotten worse for many people.
John Wilson July 16, 2012 at 02:22 pm
Keith Best - Women’s health care, more specifically, as this is what he is targeting, women’s reproductive rights, are not the rightful purview of a congressman gone completely amok – he lost his loin cloth and cannot find his cave – nor is it the rightful purview of a religious affiliated institution. The rightful purview here is between the woman and her chosen physician…
In closing, let me state here that TRUE places of religion do enjoy a TAX EXEMPT STATUS – even though by any cogent and reasonable standard they are businesses – loosely affiliated religious institutions do not enjoy that status. The tax burden for every American is greatly increased because these TRUE places of religion are TAX EXEMPT, never pay any money into the support of the country, and yet, feel free to use their money and influence in the background to undermine the very secular institutions that allow them to exist. This makes LOBBYISTS look downright saintly…
sparky July 16, 2012 at 02:31 pm
Considering the Congresmans family made bundles on feminine hygene products you would think he would be more sympathetic towards womens healthcare.
Lyle Ruble July 16, 2012 at 02:41 pm
@Keith Best...It's all about your "Chatty Cathy" talking points. There is nothing new that you have to add. Your nothing but the Waukesha County Republican Party Mouth Piece.
St. Swithin July 16, 2012 at 02:54 pm
@Cowdung -
link for the "many reports" that rate Romneycare a failure, please? As for cost controls, Obamacare contains quite a few - There are limits to how much insurance can raise prices; standards for the ratio of care to overhead an insurance company can spend, and the whole thing is tied in with Medicaid/Medicare cost controls. It's quite a kludge, in my opinion, but it breaks the Republican stonewalling of the past two decades and hopefully can be refined in the future. In fact, some of the worst parts have already been changed in Congress. If people like Rep S would actually offer sensible tweaks to the ACA instead of posturing about religious freedoms the whole country would be better off.
Greg July 16, 2012 at 02:55 pm
Womens health care??? Do they have a cold?
CowDung July 16, 2012 at 02:58 pm
http://www.healthcarefinancenews.com/news/pnhp-massachusetts-healthcare-system-failure
http://www.healthleadersmedia.com/content.cfm?content_id=228526&page=1&topic=WS_HLM2_HEP http://www.pnhp.org/news/2009/february/massachusetts_is_no_.php
Keith Best July 16, 2012 at 03:41 pm
@Lyle Ruble-- I write exactly what I believe. If you can't understand that, that's your problem.
I don't resort to name calling or personal attacks. I represent my views as well as the Republican Party of Waukesha County, since they coincide. You may disagree and that is your right, but I will continue to write what I believe, and am proud to do so.
Patrick July 16, 2012 at 03:41 pm
I encourage everyone to read for themselves the link attached. This is a short read from Forbes (conservative), speaks directly to the successes of the model used to craft the national reform. Contrary to all the rhetoric above, ITS WORKING and VERY popular among citizens and businesses alike. The public is done being fooled.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/kenrapoza/2012/01/20/romney-care-massachusetts-healthcare-reform/
St. Swithin July 16, 2012 at 04:54 pm
@Cowdung
Thanks for the links. However all three links point to the same study. That study states that the main problems with 'Romneycare' are the rising premiums and unnecessary overhead at the insurance companies. Obamacare addresses these issues. Also, the study recommends "a national, nonprofit, single-payer system" as a way to solve these issues. I like it! How about you?
CowDung July 16, 2012 at 05:11 pm
The trouble is that Obamacare will end up driving the insurance companies out of business. You can't demand that they accept people with pre-existing conditions without financial penalty and have no caps on payouts and then cap the cost of the premiums. Even the 'fines' that are required for those that don't buy insurance are bad--it's cheaper to pay the fine and only buy insurance when you need it, and drop it again when you don't.
Greg July 16, 2012 at 06:43 pm
As the linked article clearly shows, the ACA is something that should have been implemented at a state level. Massachusetts went through a lot of hoops and great expense to get a couple of percent more people covered.
I don't know that I consider Forbes "(conservative)", but I don't think the author is even close to conservative. His normal beat is Russia and China, not health care. Do you understand that the ACA is probably not going to be "free" for anyone that has to pay now? If you are one bill away from financial ruin, the ACA may not be a great savior. You say "The public is done being fooled", I say, as the public, I still don't have enough answers.
Johnny Seed July 16, 2012 at 06:51 pm
Cowdung- You have it wrong and Patrick is on point. Right now we pay for all the medical care of those uninsured already. Anyone can tell you medical costs are overinflated to cover the uninsured this is common knowledge, what is wrong with making uninsured contribute to there medical care. And if you think insurance companies are going to go out of business your crazy, the profits and CEO pay is astronomical. Generally the people that are complaining to our congressmen are the ones that have something to lose, in this case its most frauds and cheats. Affordable Healthcare Obamacare protects the middle class taxpayers and provides a safety net for some poor while asking them to make a contribution to there healthcare.
CowDung July 16, 2012 at 07:02 pm
How exactly are the poor going to be able to make a contribution to their healthcare costs? One of the issues with Romneycare is that people that used to get free health care are now having to pay for it...
John Wilson July 16, 2012 at 08:04 pm
Greg - Let me see now, ACA passed into law on March 13, 2010, that was 2-years, 4-months and 3-days ago. The Internet is replete with government information regarding the PPACA bill, including the actual bill; practically everyone in America has been discussing this bill, since its passage; insurance sites. AARP and many other sites have put out massive amounts of good information on this bill... and yet, you, speaking for all the public, "still don't have enough answers."
A suggestion, GOYA, Get Off Your Ass and READ! There is simply no excuse, especially after all this time has passed, for any reasonably intelligent citizen of this country to claim ignorance or lack of knowledge on something that effects EVERYONE, and 18% of our GDP...
Greg July 16, 2012 at 08:54 pm
SIUYA, I have read YPA. No excuse? So you completely understand how the ACA will affect every citizen, the health care industry, the health insurance industry, state taxes, federal taxes, etc.? YAFOS.
Keith Schmitz July 16, 2012 at 08:56 pm
Somebody shows up with a Keith Best doll, pulls its string, and out comes is any one of 15 delight whacko phrases.
Keith Schmitz July 16, 2012 at 08:57 pm
Think you are looking for the word uppity.
Keith Schmitz July 16, 2012 at 09:00 pm
State's rights is another flimsy phrase for coming out with a way for the states to avoid doing something.
Keith Schmitz July 16, 2012 at 09:01 pm
Why do you weep for the health insurance? They will have plenty in the way of profit and if they don't, no lose because they add nothing to the health care delivery system.
Keith Schmitz July 16, 2012 at 09:02 pm
Did we send him to Washington to lie to us?
Johnny Seed July 16, 2012 at 10:31 pm
Cowdung- Wisconsin was part of test for affordable healthcare bill it is called Badgercare Plus it provides low income familys a way to provide low cost health insurance for there children. A couple of years ago my friends income was reduced by 40% for about 10 months and they were able to pay 23.00 a month to insure their 9 year old son.
Geoff Tolley July 17, 2012 at 05:48 pm
CowDung said: "The trouble is that Obamacare will end up driving the insurance companies out of business. You can't demand that they accept people with pre-existing conditions without financial penalty and have no caps on payouts and then cap the cost of the premiums"
The cost of premiums is capped to 125% of the amount spent on actual healthcare in the case of individual policies. Since spending on the healthcare of those with pre-existing conditions and those who require a lot of medical attention is wholly included in the latter, the only insurance companies that will go out of business are the ones that are grossly inefficient at providing actual healthcare to their customers who are paying for it. Some state markets are dominated by utterly inefficient insurance companies, which is why the PPACA allows states with utterly inefficient markets to apply for temporary relaxations of this requirement to give such companies time to become more efficient so as to avoid their exit from the individual policy marketplace altogether. Some such waivers are granted; some are not. Efficient insurance companies will survive and thrive; those which exist simply to exploit policyholders to pay for their own bureaucracy will not.
Bert July 19, 2012 at 09:19 pm
Dung - Obamacare reduces the cost of that uninsured individuals place on the rest of us in two ways. For those who can afford insurance but choose not to purchase it, they now must purchase it. Thus, when they catch a bad case of the cancer, you and I don't get stuck with the bill. For those who can't afford insurance and will take advantage of the subsidies in Obamacare to gain coverage, the fact that they will now be getting preventative care that they couldn't afford before means that they will be less likely to end up in the (much more expensive) ER with a serious preventable illness.
As for the affordability of this package, it's not only the model in MA, but in a bunch of other countries as well. Germany, for example, has the same kind of mandated system provided for by private insurance companies. The system works well, is solvent, and the private companies remain profitable. The whole "sky is falling" argument about this is simple fear-mongering, that ignores the realities of every other similar system already in existence as well as the numerous studies that have shown how the plan will work.
Bert July 19, 2012 at 09:23 pm
ACA leaves the states a ton of leeway in designing their own insurance exchanges for individuals. It also provides significantly more money for the states to use to expand the low-income health programs they already have.
Bernard Forand October 1, 2012 at 02:59 pm
KEY word here is AFFILATED! Any religion conducting a business that is directed to the secular Free Trade Markets will abide by the law. Including Taxes, Insurances, Education, Hospitals and so on, that fall into the secular domains’. Its not for religions’ to continuously seek to rewrite our secular laws. Those Freedom Of Religion laws are there to protect religions. They are not there for any religion to use to lobby some representative to advance their desires to infiltrate our secular laws on the separation of church and government. When they do. They need to be held accountable from the micro infraction to the macro. F James should already have knowledge of this. This action he is advocating is in defiant to our U.S. Constitution. This a leader???
John Wilson October 1, 2012 at 04:12 pm
Patrick -
Great reply! Senselessbrenner has always found ways to "stir the pot" create divisiveness and fear among the masses. If this was a different era, he would be our HITLER! This buffoon is a total waste to the human gene pool...
John Wilson October 1, 2012 at 04:16 pm
Keith Best -
I want freedom FROM religion! You flat-earthers have just about killed everything beautiful on this planet!

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Waukesha Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Matt Schroeder (Editor) June 16, 2013 at 10:08 pm
Dawn: Can you tell me about a block or location where it's happening? We might be able to work on aRead More story this week on Patch.
Nancy June 16, 2013 at 10:53 pm
Our spruce trees have been dying as well. Very slowly. This is on upper Coventry lane just acrossRead More from the walkway to Meadowbrook school.
Dori June 17, 2013 at 07:39 am
We lost bushes also. I assumed it was from last summer's drought. We're located near Hy59 andRead More Sunset. I noticed dead trees at Prairie View and Sunset also.
Driving School June 17, 2013 at 12:58 pm
Classes started today!! Students are still able to attend this session by coming to class no laterRead More than tomorrow at 10:00 am. Call our office for directions and enrollment 414-447-0202.
Pennyluhu June 16, 2013 at 07:49 am
I agree that the folks at this Kwik Trip are great at assisting disabled people like myself but IRead More disagree that all Kwik Trips are helpful. There is a law that all gas stations are to assist you if you have disabled plates or a hanging placard if you press the help or disabled key on the pump. If there is no key (and I think all must have them by a certain date) then you are to honk horn twice and if there are at least 2 employees on duty, they are to assist. The K/T on St. Paul is useless. I've waited there, watching at least 3 employees mill around the counter with 1 or 2 customers and ingnore me. The Grandview station same but I haven't tried them in a few months. The worst station for that is whatever the one on St. Paul and Prarie is. I pulled in to see a female worker standing on side of building smoking. When she went in she was greeted by a male worker and I was ignored by both. I'd like to do a survey on how helpful each gas station is to the disabled. Kudos to Fleetfoot Kwik Trip! Whatever they got they should share with their brethren. I would rather give my $ to K/T because they are WI based and they donate regularly to the Salvation Army
Pennyluhu June 16, 2013 at 07:49 am
I agree that the folks at this Kwik Trip are great at assisting disabled people like myself but IRead More disagree that all Kwik Trips are helpful. There is a law that all gas stations are to assist you if you have disabled plates or a hanging placard if you press the help or disabled key on the pump. If there is no key (and I think all must have them by a certain date) then you are to honk horn twice and if there are at least 2 employees on duty, they are to assist. The K/T on St. Paul is useless. I've waited there, watching at least 3 employees mill around the counter with 1 or 2 customers and ingnore me. The Grandview station same but I haven't tried them in a few months. The worst station for that is whatever the one on St. Paul and Prarie is. I pulled in to see a female worker standing on side of building smoking. When she went in she was greeted by a male worker and I was ignored by both. I'd like to do a survey on how helpful each gas station is to the disabled. Kudos to Fleetfoot Kwik Trip! Whatever they got they should share with their brethren. I would rather give my $ to K/T because they are WI based and they donate regularly to the Salvation Army
Mr Lundt June 17, 2013 at 08:02 am
I am fine with this service--its great. However being handicapped does not mean employees need toRead More give up their breaks or other customers need to let you cut in line in front of their service needs.
Tj June 13, 2013 at 04:22 pm
Will these need water? Because the Garden Center at Target has great deals on "no water"Read More tomato plants, which would surely save me some much needed General Assistance money.
Kathy Spancrete June 13, 2013 at 09:14 pm
According to a recent episode of Judge Judy, tomatoes can be both poisonous and deadly. When IRead More called the posted phone number asking for a simple answer to my many serious questions, and all they did was put me on hold -- repeatedly. I cannot recommend a company that refuses to stand behind its own product, much less pick up the phone.
Collin Richter, Waukesha North Badger Boys State Representative
BRM Management June 10, 2013 at 05:16 pm
Update! Collin was just selected as one of two STATE TROOPERS for Dodge County. He and otherRead More representatives were interviewed yesterday. Word is that he may be assisting Governor Scott Walker off the helicopter when he arrives at Badger Boys State later this week. Governor Walker is a past Badger Boys State representative.
Sarah Millard (Editor) June 10, 2013 at 06:02 pm
Thanks for sharing and congrats Collin!
Sarah Millard (Editor) June 10, 2013 at 12:44 pm
Great shot! Congratulations to all graduating seniors :)
Trenace Ransom-Overstreet June 10, 2013 at 02:19 pm
So Proud of Meech. He has had a terrible year with the lost of his mother. But he still graduated.Read More God's Blessing on your future!!